MLB and the Art of Instant Replay

On August 28, 2008, MLB implemented a replay system which assists the umpiring crew with questionable calls.  As of now, the replay system can only be used on a few defined circumstances.  Instant replay can only be initiated by the umpiring crew, and the only types of plays that a call can be reversed are:

• Home runs (fair/foul)
• Whether or not the ball actually left the playing field
• Fan interference

While 2008 proved to be a good start for this new system, we find 2009 utilizing the instant replay much more often.  To the typical fan, the use of instant replay only helps the game, but to a hardcore fan, there are other repercussions that are not easily seen through the naked eye.  As I have spent some time pondering the pros and cons of this new system, I have come to be a fan who is not in favor of the system.  Listed below are few pros and cons on instant replay, followed by my own personal thoughts.

Pros

1. Plain and simple, a botched call (especially on a game changing home run), can have a huge impact on a team and its fans.  The use of instant replay to overrule the on-field call could alter the outcome of a game.
2. It provides accountability for umpires.  Let’s be honest… no one wants to make mistakes, and if there is a way to ensure complete perfection, this is a great way to do so.
3. The system *should* be quick and flawless.  There is an emphasis on ’should’ which I will explain shortly.
4. MLB is keeping up with the technological advances today.  As the world changes, everything around us needs to adapt.

Cons

1. The system *is* slow.  By the time the umpires convene to discuss, they have already wasted 3-4 minutes.  Then to go to the monitor to check the replay could take another 3-4 minutes.  So in all, the instant replay system takes about 7-8 minutes each time.  From a pitching perspective, this could prove bothersome.  To stand on the mound while the umpires discuss the call completely ruins a pitchers rhythm (which is everything to a pitcher).
2. If MLB tries to enhance the instant replay to every minute facet of the game (i.e. close plays at first; balls/strikes), it would create a horrible fan and player experience.
3. We are all human, and make mistakes.  Why should umpires be any different?  The human factor of the sport is what makes it something we can all relate to.

I personally am not in favor of instant replay.  Sure, when a call goes my way, of course I’ll be thrilled; however, I feel this new system takes away from the integrity of the game.  The game went on for 100+ years without the use of instant replay.  Why change that now?  We are all human and make mistakes.  There are 4 umpires on the field throughout the game.  The call they make, should be the call that stays.

Should instant replay be a part of baseball?  Have your say below!